Worried about a Recession or Stock Market Crash?
Here's How Precious Metals Perform
Convinced a recession is here? Worried the stock market isn’t done crashing?
It’s a distinct possibility things could get worse.
Which raises a natural question: how does gold—and all precious metals for that matter—perform during these events?
If we use history as a guide, there’s a clear tendency with all of them…
Precious Metals vs. Recessions
The most common definition of a recession is two consecutive quarters of negative gross domestic production (GDP). Given the way it’s calculated, it is a lagging indicator—we don’t know we’re officially in one until six months has passed (those claiming we’re in one now could easily be right).
Since 1970, there have been eight recessions in the US. We measured how each of the major precious metals—gold, silver, platinum, and palladium—performed during the official time frame of each recession.
First up, here’s how gold has performed during each of those periods of negative economic growth.
In six of the eight modern-day recessions, the price of gold was higher at the end than when it began. The two declines were mild, with the 1980 one occurring just after its biggest percentage gain in history.
This is encouraging for investors: gold rose during the recession after 9/11… it rose during the Great Financial Crisis… and it rose during the Covid recession. In other words, some of the worst modern-day crises led to higher gold prices.
This makes sense when you think about it. A slowing economy usually increases fear among investors, and gold is a natural refuge when uncertainty strikes.
A recent Bloomberg study also compared gold to the S&P 500 during each of the last seven recessions. In their study, they examined the two-year period around each recession—the 12 months before it started to 12 months after it began—and found gold outperformed the S&P 500 by about 50% on average.
- History clearly shows gold can hedge a portfolio during recessions.
Let’s look at the other precious metals…
Here’s how silver has historically performed during recessions.
Silver has not fared as well during recessionary periods. This also makes sense when you think about it, since roughly 55% of all silver goes to industrial uses, and commerce slows during economic downturns.
Here’s platinum and palladium.
Platinum has fallen in every recession since 1970, except once when the price was flat.
Palladium has likewise fallen in every recession except one.
Since roughly 90% of all platinum and palladium is used in vehicles, it’s not surprising they have fallen during recessions, when automotive demand would decline.
Precious Metals vs. Stock Market Crashes
A stock market crash can be hard on an investment portfolio. Do precious metals help?
There have been 10 stock market crashes in the past 50 years. We used the S&P 500 and looked at each crash of 19% or more.
This chart measures how each precious metal fared during the specific timeframe of each crash.
History shows that gold usually rises during stock market crashes. Of the three times it fell, two were less than the S&P, and the only one greater was coincidentally just after its biggest price rise in history.
Silver is a bit more of a mixed bag. It usually declines when stocks sell off, though half of the time that decline has been less than the S&P.
Platinum and palladium have not fared well. After the 1970s, only once has platinum risen, and palladium never has.
Keep in mind this measures performance only during the crash itself, not what happens afterward.
The historical record shows that gold performs better than other precious metals during recessions and stock market crashes. When fear and uncertainty strike the economy or markets, gold has served as a natural hedge. This is one of the reasons we encourage everyone to own some gold, along with their silver.
Gold is more than a fear trade, though. It’s money. That fact will become more and more clear to everyone as the monetary system gets weaker and weaker. It’s a once in a lifetime transition that will make each one of us either a victim or a victor.
The path to being a victor is clear. Own humankind’s oldest form of money.
Here’s an easy and inexpensive way to accumulate it.
Jeff Clark utilizes his knowledge of the gold mining industry, a family legacy, from prospecting and exploration to the financial and capital markets to produce Casey Research's BIG GOLD investment newsletter.
Working the family placer and hardrock claims in California, Nevada, and Arizona taught Jeff what to look for when investigating the merits of a prospective property. Learning from his father, an award-winning panner with a history of successful stakes, Jeff regularly visits gold and silver projects to assess their economic and geological potential, examine drill core, tour operations and drill targets, and meet with the management team and even workers to dig deep into their operations and potential.
Making money in the precious metals industry—for both himself and his subscribers—is what drives Jeff. He's constantly researching companies to recommend, analyzing the big trends in precious metals, and looking for safe and profitable ways to capitalize on the gold and silver bull market. He puts his money where his mouth is, and is completely committed to making BIG GOLD the best precious metals advisory for the prudent investor.
Jeff is a regular speaker at the industry's top investment conferences, such as the Vancouver Resource Investment Conference, the Silver Summit, and the Sprott Natural Resource Symposium. Jeff is also regularly quoted in notable business press, including MarketWatch, TheStreet, Kitco, Hard Assets Investor, and the Washington Post. He's sought after for his big-picture view of the gold and silver markets, as well as the implications of daily market moves on the underlying fundamentals. He focuses on mid- to large-cap precious metals, ETFs, mutual funds, and of course various forms of bullion. A well-rounded expert commentator with a very approachable and entertaining style, Jeff is known for helping readers make sense of the frequent changes in the price of gold and silver, the direction of metals and mining equities, and what place precious metals of all types have in an investor's portfolio.
Jeff's publication, BIG GOLD, is ideal for subscribers who are new to the world of precious metals investing, or who are looking for independent analysis of the many options out there for gold, silver, and other precious metals investments.